Skip to main content

Table 8 Comparison

From: Safety of total hip arthroplasty for femoral neck fractures using the direct anterior approach: a retrospective observational study in 86 elderly patients

  Approach Age (years) Patients Follow-up (months) Dislocation (%) HHS SF-36 Mean Physical/Mental
Baker [33] Lateral 74 40 36 7.5   40.53/52
Blomfeldt [38] Anterolateral 81 60 12 0 87.2  
Dorr [34] Posterior 69 39 48 17.9   
Keating [35] Posterior/Lateral 75 69 24 4   
Jaquot [23] Postero-posterolateral 79 102 1.5 0   
Macaulay [10] Posterolat/Anterolateral 82 17 24 5.8 84.2 40.2/55.7
Park [3] 2-incision 72 44 24 4.5 88.3  
Mouzopoulos [39] NS 73 43 48 0 83.7  
Skinner [36] Posterolateral 81 89 12 15.7   
Van den Bekerom [37] Posterolateral/(Antero)lateral 82 115 60 7 75.2  
Wani [2] Posterolateral 65 50 18 0 93.7  
Burgers [7] Meta-Analysis     8.9 81  
Yu & Wang [6] Meta-Analysis     7.6   
Zi-Sheng [5] Meta-Analysis 69-81 561 12-156 17.2   
OUR Anterior 75 86 20 2.3 94 41.3/51.9