Table 1 Outcome studies of operative treatment of displaced acetabular fractures listed in order of number of cases surgically treated with follow-up, year of publication, country of origin, number of cases, average follow-up period (F/U yrs), G-E results OR survivorship (% survival at 10 or 20 yrs), and negative prognostic factors
From: Outcomes after surgical treatment of acetabular fractures: a review
Author | Year | Country | Cases (F/U yrs) | G-E Result/Survivorship | Negative prognostic factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tannast/Matta et al [3] | 2012 | USA | 816 (2–20) | 85% (10YR) 79% (20 YRS) | FHI, PW, AGE, DISP, MI |
Letournel/Judet [4] | 1993 | FRANCE | 492 (1–33) | 80% | PC/PW, AW, PR |
Mears et al [48] | 2003 | USA | 424 (9.3) | 89% | PR, FN, DEL > 11, AF, SI, FHI, OB, AW, AGE |
Matta [20] | 1996 | USA | 255 (6) | 76% | AGE, FHI, SI, TT/PW |
Clarke-Jenssen et al [49] | 2017 | NORWAY | 253 (12) | 86% (10YRS) | FHI, SI |
Madhu et al [53] | 2006 | UK | 237 (2.9) | 76% | DEL > 15 (EF), DEL > 10(AF) |
Murphy et ala [65] | 2003 | IRELAND | 180 (6.3) | 78% | AF, AGE, PR > 3, HO, LC |
Rommens et al [66] | 1997 | BELGIUM | 175 (2) | 76% | TT/PW |
Mayo [67] | 1994 | USA | 163 (3.7) | 75% | – |
Briffa et al [26] | 2011 | UK | 161 (11.3) | 72% | AGE, DEL > 15, PR, PC/TT, FHI |
Pennal et ala [51] | 1980 | CANADA | 103 (7.25) | – | FX, WB, PR, AGE, PELVIS |
Wright et al [56] | 1994 | USA | 87 (3.6) | 45% | DL, HO, AVN, AGE, PR, EXP |
Zha et alb [23] | 2013 | CHINA | 86 (3.2) | 84% | CPWF, FHI, PR |
Fica et al [68] | 1998 | CHILE | 84 (5.5) | 67% | TT, PR, AGE, AVN |
Zhi et al [69] | 2011 | CHINA | 82 (2.8) | 71% | FX, AGE, LE FX, PR, DEL, DL |
Rommens et al [50] | 2011 | GERMANY | 77 (3.7) | 70% | CPWF, SI, IAF |
Almedia et al [70] | 2011 | BRAZIL | 76 (4.9) | 81% | PR, LOR, DI |
Deo et al [71] | 2001 | UK | 74 (2.6) | 74% | FH, PR, NERVE/DL |
Chen et al [72] | 2000 | TAIWAN | 73 (7.5) | 74% | PR |
Uchida et al [73] | 2013 | JAPAN | 71 (8.6) | 90% | PR, AVN, SI |
Ragnarsson et al [74] | 1992 | SWEDEN | 55 (15) | 60% | PR |
Heeg et al [75] | 1990 | HOLLAND | 54 (9.6) | 61% | PR, HO |
Kebaish et al [54] | 1991 | CANADA | 54 (4.7) | 86% | EXP, PR |
Ruesch/Mast et al [76] | 1994 | USA | 53 (1+) | 81% | N/A |
De Ridder et al [55] | 1994 | HOLLAND | 51 (3) | 76% | – |
Oranksy et al [77] | 1993 | ITALY | 50 (3.5) | 76% | DEL > 21, PR, EXP |
Chiu et alc [33] | 1996 | CHINA | 27 (7) | 81% | – |
Brueton [78] | 1993 | UK | 26 (2.2) | 61% | PR, DEL > 17 |