Skip to main content

Table 2 Individual and environmental characteristics

From: Exploring unnecessary invasive procedures in the United States: a retrospective mixed-methods analysis of cases from 2008-2016

Physician Description

 Significant personal problems

11.4%

 Age > 49 years old

48.1%

 Poor professional skills

12.7%

 Gender: Male

96.2%

 Claimed cases as uniquely difficult

12.7%

 Born outside the US

27.8%

Relationship to Industrya

 

 Trained outside the US

40.5%

 Gifts

3.8%

 Specialty

 

 Consulting/Authorship/Speaking

8.9%

  Internal/General

8.9%

 Grants for education or research

3.8%

  OB/GYN

3.8%

 Ownership interest

8.9%

  Psychiatry/Neurology

1.3%

 Physician owned distributorship

2.5%

  Pediatrics/Family

5.1%

 Other relationship to industry

11.4%

  Anesthesiology

6.3%

Workplace

 

  Other surgery/emergency/ENT

7.6%

 Non-Academic, Private Practice

92.4%

  Urology

3.8%

Physician practice size

 

  Cardiology/Interventional

26.6%

 Solo

17.7%

  Neurosurgery

10.1%

 Small (2–3 physicians)

12.7%

  Orthopedics/Surgery

10.1%

 Large (≥ 4 physicians)

55.7%

  Oncology

6.3%

 Other/Unknown

13.9%

  Other

10.1%

Physician ownership

 

 Board certified

70.9%

 Solo

29.1%

 Antisocial personality traits

48.1%

 Joint

13.9%

 Engaged in unrelated illegal actions

21.5%

 Employee

45.6%

 Evidence of severe mental illness

1.3%

 Other/Unknown Motive

11.4%

 Substance addiction

2.5%

Accomplice involved

57.0%

  1. aRelationships to industry means that reports on the unnecessary procedures mentioned such relationships. The cases investigated occurred before the Physician Payments Sunshine Act was effective, so no publicly available database of relationships existed. Total percent with any kind of relationship was 24.1%